Hindenburg Shorts Carvana, Alleging ‘Grift for the Ages’

Key Points

  • Hindenburg Research accused Carvana Co. of impropriety, claiming its subprime loan portfolio carries substantial risk and its growth is unsustainable.
  • Carvana's shares fell 1.9% after the report, despite a 284% surge in stock value the previous year.
  • The report alleges Carvana uses lax underwriting standards and manipulates results through transactions with a company owned by CEO Ernest Garcia III's father.
  • Carvana dismissed the allegations as misleading and previously made by other short sellers.

Summary

Carvana Co., an online auto retailer, has been accused by Hindenburg Research of engaging in questionable business practices. The report claims that Carvana's subprime loan portfolio poses significant risks and that the company's growth model is unsustainable. Hindenburg, after taking a short position on Carvana's stock, highlighted issues like lax loan underwriting and the manipulation of financial results through dealings with DriveTime, a car dealer owned by the CEO's father. Despite these allegations, Carvana's stock had seen a dramatic 284% increase in value the previous year, although it dropped by 1.9% following the report's release. Carvana responded by stating that the accusations were not new and had been made by other short sellers in the past, suggesting that the company has been under scrutiny since its IPO seven years ago. The report also pointed out insider trading by the Garcia family, with significant stock sales during periods of stock price surges.

yahoo
January 2, 2025
Stocks
Read article

Related news